David Wolfe:
August 19, 2017
Dear Paul Watson,
I first became aware of you, Sea Shepard, and your mission while watching Whale Wars on Animal Planet. I was surprised at how enjoyable it was to watch you and your crew defend animals. It is a rare thing to come across people and persons who understand that animals are more than a food source, and that animals are sentient beings. We have always had cats in our family ever since I can remember, birds and fish too. Hearing you speak about your own personal story of how you came to greater understanding of animals I wanted to share with you some of my own personal stories.
As a family in my early teens we vacationed in Florida. We visited both Busch Gardens and Sea World. I was never a child that liked to wander off alone. If you’ve ever been separated and lost at an early age it’s a lesson you don’t forget. We all sat down in an outdoor auditorium for a show, then in walked elephants onto the stage. The performer started to climb on the elephant to sit on top wearing shoes with a heel. I cringed. I squirmed in my seat. I closed my eyes. I cringed even more. The trainer began speaking about how tough elephant skin is. I couldn’t stop cringing, my insides, my outsides cringing. I couldn’t stand to watch it. It was not entertainment to me. I disbelieved that the trainer could fully measure the nerve endings under the dermis of the elephant, or know the difference between the elephant being in pain and the elephant allowing the performer to walk on him. I walked out of the auditorium. The show had just begun and I had to walk out. It hurt just to watch.
When we got to Sea World, the Orca show was one of the first things we did that day. It is a huge auditorium. It is also a very specific environment. Mind you, I was interested and excited to be at these places, however it was not very long into the show. I was overcome. In that auditorium specifically, and on that day, at that time. There was such a sadness that came over me. It was heavy, not a screaming pain, it was an unbearable sadness like I had not yet experienced. Sadness as a crushing weight as heavy and as expansive as the ocean itself filling the entire auditorium. Sadness. Sadness. Sad. Such sadness. I believe it was coming from the whales, or whales talking to each other, or simply a whale – feeling. Sadness. Sadness. It was so unbearably painful to feel the sadness. I couldn’t sit to watch, I was not entertained. Sadness. Such sadness.
We eventually moved to Florida from Oregon. Living in a small apartment, I was grateful for the ponds beside our complex which provided lots of wildlife watching. We had a small raft that we would paddle around on in this very small pond. Otters would come up to the raft curiously. There were ducks, egrets, herons, and all sorts of birds. It was a huge culture shock moving to Florida, so I took the opportunity to learn all about the wildlife. I used to feed the ducks every day, so I could be outside and not cooped up in the A/C’ed apartment. The ducks seemed to have greater intelligence than the Floridians I had met. I named all the ducks. The ducks could be flying in the air, and if I called their name they would stop, turn around in flight, and come to me.
So, Floridians. One day I came upon one of the ducks I used to feed and he no longer resembled a duck. He looked like someone had taken a baseball bat to him, killing him. Rage like I have never experienced hurt and saddened me. For maybe I was also to blame for feeding the ducks. No animal deserves to be abused.
Half-singing, half-running, half-jumping, half-skipping my way into the kitchen of our apartment, my brother had been experimenting with something he read about removing tarnish from silver using boiling water, aluminum foil, and some other things when I did not notice the handle from the pot sticking out from the range knocking the boiling water down my leg. I am sure I screamed. Standing there in the kitchen looking at my knit pants wet-stuck to my skin, I heard my mother screaming take your pants off. I am not kidding you, my first reaction was, I don’t think so. I mean come on. It’s funny where your mind goes even in an emergency. Begrudgingly, I took off my pants. The skin came off with the pants. My mother quickly gets me into a cool bath as she is calling a nurse friend asking for advice.
Wrapped in gauze and fresh pants, I slowly began to sit down to watch some television. Our cat, Barney who never behaved as a cat, but more as an English gentlemen patient with his human family, started as if he was going to jump in my lap. I didn’t and couldn’t move too quickly or say anything fast enough when he jumped up onto my lap with a knowing I cannot explain. He was careful. He was cautious. He curled up exactly where my burn was, and as if he had a timer he jumped down almost as though he knew his job was done. There was no pain when he curled up in my lap. There was never pain again from that burn, nor has there ever been a scar which I give Barney credit for helping me heal.
My beautiful cat Thursday that was adopted from a local vet, was one of the smartest, sweetest cats I’ve ever had. He only had two claws on one paw, yet he still loved to jump. However, sometimes he would limp after jumping down. After moving into my current townhouse, he started peeing around the townhouse. Usually at the worst possible moment. I would run to him screaming what are you doing, you know better than to do that?! I could see from his eyes he did not want to pee or do a bad behavior. I could see in his eyes he had no choice. I could see in his eyes he was somehow being controlled either through a silent whistle or some command that I could not see or hear. It terrorized both he and I. It is still unbearably painful knowing that my animals are used in this townhouse without my permission and my control. I share that for a very specific purpose. It is one thing to steal from me, take control over me, abuse me – it is another matter entirely to use and abuse my own cat(s) against my wishes and control.
Before I went to college, I took a trip to Boston. Got off on the wrong train stop, and had to walk forever to get to the hotel in the brutal Boston heat. Exhausted from the trip to the hotel, I collapsed on my bed trying to cool off in the A/C. I did not have my eyes closed very long before I heard with absolute certainty my cat Mouse meow with unnatural pain. I ran to the window to see if there was anything there. All I saw was a factory – the NECCO factory. Upon my return home, my mother told me how Mouse had become suddenly ill and had to be put down. I asked for the time it had occurred. It was nearly to the minute I heard him cry miles and miles away.
Babee Bear was named because he looked just like a little black bear, he had a Manx tail. I was there for his birth, but was not prepared, nor did I understand how I could help his mother. I left for a short time during the still-birthed deliveries to return to bodiless kittens. Babee Bear was the last cat delivered whose mother could not get him to breathe. So, I took the little black baby cat in my hands trying to work air into the lungs. It didn’t work, and it didn’t work, and it didn’t work, and it didn’t work, and it didn’t work, and it didn’t work. I don’t know how many times I gave up trying to will life into his lungs. Finally, he started moving around and he came to life. His mother rejected him. She would not nurse him. Because of that he had no personality at all. To look in his eyes was to look into emptiness. I worked an overnight shift, so sleep was precious and hard to come by. One day, I took Bear with me as I went to sleep. I told him he could sleep on the pillow next to me and he was not allowed to move while I slept. I talked to him for a few minutes telling him of fun and playtime we would have when I would wake, and reminded him how long I was going to sleep, and for him not to move, just sleep while I slept. I was surprised when I woke up to find him unmoved. I don’t think he even walked around the room or anything. I picked him up and took him with me into the rest of the house. From that day on he was never a no-personality, or emptied eyed cat. We had a real animal-human bond. He would listen to me with understanding, he even did little things like lay his head on my hand while being examined at a vet’s visit. Very few people get to experience a real animal-human bond like that.
Animals do feel grief. I have witnessed it.
I had a cat Friday whom I called Friday because he turned his head as a kitten when I asked him what he wanted his name to be. He loved the sound of the Ffff in Friday. Everybody loved Friday. Nearly every person that visited our house tried to take Friday home. No joke, I mean everyone wanted Friday as their own. I had a neighbor, Don who used to come by just to visit Friday. Friday greeted every person that visited our home as if he was as important and valued as his human family, and capable of communicating too.
Sundae was named for what appeared to be ice cream scoops on her back that resembled a sundae. One day she started having trouble breathing, the next day she had to be put down as x-rays revealed cancer throughout her lungs and her heart had nearly doubled in size. Friday and Sundae had never been particularly close, yet when Sundae died Friday soon stopped eating. He would come running at meal times eat a bite or two, stop quickly, and hang his head. He started to stare out the windows at a single point not moving his head or body. As if his whole body was alert, stiffened, on alert waiting for her return. On occasion, he would walk into the room with such a stilled air it called my attention. He would then slowly, carefully lie down where Sundae used to sleep, never moving, barely breathing. Grieving. It was more than sadness.
He started to lose so much weight I took him to the vet every day – even Saturday and Sunday the vet showed up just for me – for a week until I got up the nerve to ask the vet if it was helping at all. You see, my mother had her first big stroke shortly after Sundae’s death. One more sick or dying person or animal was more than I could bear or manage. Graciously, the vet told me he did not believe it was helping Friday to get well. I had no choice, but to put him down. However, I believe he really died from grief, and the loss of his mate for she had the same last name – day.
Perhaps this is too much to share with you. Perhaps, you may understand, or perhaps you might view me as crazy. However, these experiences and more have caused me to believe animals are best when they are understood as more than creatures. It is also a rare gift some people have being able to communicate and understand animals. It is a rare gift to be able to believe beyond explanation too.
Thank you and your crew for all the hard work you do.
Sincerely,
Cherith J Gjestland